Aaron Sorkin's The Social Reckoning is, without a doubt, an important story, and even at times a compelling story. But the film manages to make this tale of recent history feel both outdated and, ultimately, rather pointless. Facebook feels like a dying brand (crocodile tears over that) and there are much bigger dangers waiting in the wings to take over and make our lives miserable.
Essentially a movie about journalism, it invites obvious comparisons to All the President's Men, perhaps the pinnacle of journalists-as-heroes cinema. Jeremy Allen White stars as Jeff Horwitz, newly hired by the San Francisco branch of the Wall Street Journal to cover Facebook, despite his being pretty tech averse in general. He is eventually contacted by Frances Haugen (Mikey Madison), a Facebook employee on the Civic Integrity Team who has begun to have concerns about the growing toxicity of the platform.
Haugen is a Facebook true believer, who hopes that by exposing what is happening - essentially that the company is putting profit over safety - Facebook will change. Madison portrays Haugen as you may expect your average tech worker to be: incredibly smart, and socially awkward. But there's also an added level of extreme toughness and guile that makes her a compelling heroine...
...which Sorkin manages to almost completely undermine by having Haugen show up to meetings with Horwitz dressed like some kind of call girl. Her explanation is it's so if she runs into anyone from work they will think she's on a date. I don't know if this actually happened or not, but it all seems like at least, an exaggeration (she basically shows up in lingerie for one meeting), or at most, a gross fictionalization (there's multiple unnecessarily skimpy outfits). But I guess Sorkin just couldn't bear to let the Anora side of Mikey Madison fade completely.
The Social Reckoning has a lot of the fast and snappy dialogue you'd expect from a Sorkin screenplay (Betty Gilpin, as Horwitz's editor, has the most fun with it), but the movie sorely lacks the kinetic energy of David Fincher's direction in The Social Network, and the now practically iconic score by Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross.
It's a potentially exciting story told in the most boring way possible, and not helped by its non-linear timeline, which jumps back and forth between 2019 and 2021, and scenes featuring Jeremy Strong's impersonation of Mark Zuckerberg, which manages to make both of them look like total weirdos.
Maybe if this movie had come out in 2022, it may have felt as urgent and timely as The Social Network did. But the resolution in The Social Reckoning is like if All the Presidents Men ended with Nixon still the President, and no repercussions for any of the key Watergate players. As important as the "Facebook Files" and Frances Haugen's testimony were, it ultimately resulted in Facebook...changing it's name to Meta.